Friday, November 28, 2008

Best International Blog: Generación Y [UPDATED X3]

As long as we're talking about blog awards...
The jury for the Deutsche Welle International Weblog Awards -- The BOBs -- has announced the winners in all 16 of the competition's categories.

Of the 11 finalists in the Best Blog category, Generación Y, a Cuban blog written by Yoani Sanchez, claimed the Jury Prize for Best Blog.

The jury said that Sanchez gives voice to an entire generation of Cubans and provides the world with a window into Cuba through her clear and poetic writing.

In addition to a slew of other obstacles in her way, Sanchez can't even post her own entries to the blog. Instead she is forced to e-mail them to friends outside of Cuba in order for her words to go online. Despite the challenges she has to overcome, she's managed to keep in contact with her readers and create a huge international community around her work.
Here's what babalu's Ziva had to say about Yoani, pictured at right, back in December of 2007 in the comments section of a babalu post that first announced Yoani's blogging.

"A recurring feature is her 12-year-old son's school. Recently, he participated in a military shooting exercise there. Her son enjoyed playing soldier, but she was outraged."

What did she expect him to learn when she brought him back to Cuba? I'm sorry, but I have to question the character of a women who would purposely return her child to be indoctrinated, to learn to be "like che." Because it was too hard on her husband, and she couldn't bear family separation? Well they are all together, in Cuba. The price? Her son, because now he belongs to castro, inc.

And a couple other babalu reader comments from that same post...
R. Martel: This woman is so full of it. Whoever wants to be blind so be it! What a bout the thousands of Cubans who were honest about their feelings in Cuba and ended up in front of a firing squad or with a sentence of 30 years. What about the 75 who received sentences up to 30 years in jail precicely because they were honest. It's obvious this woman is a tool of the inteligence aparatus.
Alberto de la Cruz: God knows I hope she is for real. I find it interesting though, that she and her family had no problem with the "revolution," in fact they believed in it, until it began hurting them during the "special period."

To be fair, babalu has since embraced Sanchez and features her posts regularly. But I find it interesting that had it not been for the rest of the world who believed in and promoted Sanchez and Generación Y from the beginning, the Cuban-American hardliner community might have well written her off as a tool of Castro and dismissed her writings as nothing more than manipulative propaganda.

- story

******

In a response to this post, babalu's Henry Gomez resorts to his typical callow name-calling and characterizations before he points out exactly what I brought up in the post...that babalu is now fully supportive of Sanchez and her efforts. I'm in total agreement with him on this issue.

However, in his retort, Gomez attempts to frame Ziva's attacks and the other comments that were directed at Sanchez as babalu's attempt to figure out who Sanchez was...
But today a genuine pig of a person has decided to go back in the Babalu archives and retrieve comments from Babalu contributors and commenters from the period during which we were trying to assess who Yoani is and what she is about.
Actually, the pigs of which Gomez speaks are the ones that attack people, like Sanchez, by questioning their character, their intentions and their loyalties when they know little or nothing about them. Those are the real pigs of the internet. And those are the pigs of Miami's proud, hard-working and respectful Cuban-American community, a community that regularly disowns these thugs even as they risk being attacked and maligned as Castroites and communists themselves.

The fact of the matter is that babalu contributors and commenters criticized, questioned and maligned Yoani Sanchez when she first started blogging. Now they support her. Those are the facts and the points I articulated in the post. Gomez can call me every name in the book for pointing out those facts and he can also play the poor victim to "the lonesome loser" [just how pitiful does that make him?] but when it comes down to it, the facts are the facts. Right there in black and white for everyone to see and judge for themselves.

And, uh, hey Gomez? Thanks for reading SFDB, bro.

******

Alex says it in the comments...
The fact remains that of all the people in the world who were reading and marveling at Yoani, it was some Cuban exiles who made her wonder "maybe I should be in jail to prove I'm legit" -and it all came from her returning to Cuba after living abroad. That's the extent of the paranoia and it's pretty sad. It takes a big stretch of the imagination not just to think Yoani was a plot to advance some supposed Raul-as-reformist PR effort but also THAT was their first thought! It has to be! Cuban's can't access internet! Cubans are thrown in jail the second they write something critical! There are spies amongst us!


******

Most appropriately, Ziva announces Yoani's award in a post today.
Her beautiful brave writing does much more than that; her writing bridges 50 years of violence enforced silence and separation of the Cuban people by the castro dictatorship. Her writing verifies the failure of the Revolution.

Ziva does not mention her previous suspicions of Sanchez and her character, nor does she rescind them.

.

30 comments:

Anonymous said...

Dont be fooled. Their late embrace is insincere at best. As Babulu wishes nothing but extreme pain and suffering upon the island of Cuba, and her inhabitants. If it were up to Babulu and company, they would just assume Sanchez starve to death. As it is one less Cuban that they have to compete with, when they begin to corrupt a free Cuba, as they have Miami.


P.S.

I used to think Val and Henry were the biggest knuckleheads. But this Ziva chick is in competition, with her crackhead silly rants. I can only pray that she soon achieves the fame and stardom that she so desperately seeks at Huffpo.

Rick said...

A: I hate to be the one to tell you, A, but those folks pride themselves on being fringe players. I mean, they printed up tee shirts saying they were proud of being called the "Miami Mafia," for God's sakes. It's their badge of honor. The more unbalanced and loony, the better.

So, if anything, they'll see being criticized by Huffpo and it's followers as an accomplishment of some type.

.

Michelle said...

Generacion Y is a very insightful blog...very well written. This prize from Deutsche Welle is the latest of many prestigious awards Sanchez has received.

Alex said...

For Babalu it's unthinkable there are people who choose to live in Cuba... in their minds they have to be collaborators of the regime or complete idiots, there's no other choice. It comes from that black or white extremist view they spouse. You can pity them or rail against them, it's the same; blind to reality and destined to live in the margins, they are as unconsecuential as they are loud. Nobody listens.

that's a fact, jack said...

I still don't get WTF Gomez is so torqued about? You said they were cool about her now and the comments are what they are.

Are they embarrassed taht they said something negative about her at some time?

Meh.

C.L.J. said...

Jack-
Babalu assumes that Rick is out to get them, rather than actually trying to understand what's been written. It fits with their "if you aren't agreeing with us 100%, then you must support Fidel" mindset.

Fantomas said...

Rara vez paso por estos lares, primera vez que comento aqui

Llegue siguiendo los rastros de un puerco solitario que vive entre nosotros elcual publico comentarios antiguos del babalu blog

C.L.J. said...

Rara vez paso por estos lares, primera vez que comento aqui

Well, if you do, you have to clean it up.

Rick said...

Would someone be so kind to translate what the Fantomas comment says? Google Translate does a lousy job.

.

Fantomas said...

Rara vez paso por estos lares, primera vez que comento aqui

Llegue siguiendo los rastros de un puerco solitario que vive entre nosotros elcual publico comentarios antiguos del babalu blog
.......................

I rarely write comments on this blog

I got here following the steps of a lonesome porky who lives among us cuban Americans who wrote old comments form the babalu archives

As explained by Mr Gomez
That's all folks

Fantomas said...

C.L.J. said...
Rara vez paso por estos lares, primera vez que comento aqui

Well, if you do, you have to clean it up.

November 28, 2008 10:15 PM

CLJ do you know me?

Recuerda siempre que son muchas caras las de Fantomas

Rick said...

So you were announcing your arrival, Fantomas? Um, well... great!

Welcome.

I think.

[shrugs]

Hey, keep to the English so this Anglo can understand. Appreciate it.

.

Fantomas said...

Listen, i got my hands full with Tellechea until Jan 2oth ( his expected closing time) , among other things

I will comment here accordingly specially if I'm welcomed , loved and not censored

I got the wisdom to keep it clean

Rick said...

You got your welcome. I'm definitely not committing to the "loved" part. And, yeah, if you keep it clean, including any Spanish you might revert to, the comment will stay.

.

nonee moose said...

That's some jackpot you just hit, Rick. Stock up on the Maalox...

Rick said...

You got that right, Nonee.

:)

.

Alex said...

Hey Fantomas, while you are translating, how about translating your comment on that same Babalu post where you say that Yoani is a tall tale and that Cuba's state security is too good to allow her to blog?

Fantomas said...

Alex , when Yoani started I had some doubts as well as many of us did. I do not kknow if you ever lived in Cuba under communism but there things " get approved" things just dont happen . The fact is that the Cuban gov did not think Yoani would become what she is today. I realized after a while that we could be witnessing a rare event with Yoani. The international recognition she quickly received helped her tremendously
I have even corresponded with her a few times via e mail. it is all good now
If you do a blog search on my blog you will find previous comments of mine in regards to Yoani. That's history bro. Moving forward and supporting her is the right thing to do

Rick said...

Well, jeez, how hard was that? I mean, that's all it takes. To acknowledge a previous position, discuss the reason for a change and confirm a new thinking on things.

And not one word critical of the person who is looking for an explanation.

Man, it's as if we're all mature adults. Amazing.

.

Dr. Hook and The Medicine Show said...

To be honest, the first in embracing and supporting Yoani since she started her blog were the guys at KillCastro and the Black Sheep of Exile. That must have ruffled some feathers at Babalu, because everything that is associated to those guys is flatly rejected by them. Those blogs are dead now, and Babalu has jumped onto Yoani's bandwagon ever since. She most probably knows who were conducting a witchhunt on her and her family.

Alex said...

Fantomas, I lived in Cuba for 24 years. So yeah, I know what state security does and what it doesn't do, and I know that they don't control everything, including internet access.

I agree, it's in the past and everybody should support Yoani now and it's loable they do. But here's the question, how do you react the next time there's a Yoani? What irks me is the distrust as a knee-jerk, first-reaction. Fine, scrutinize anything that comes out of Cuba if that's what floats your boat, but does it has to be from a suspicious or skeptical point of view? I wonder -well, I don't really wonder- what Babalu would say of my friends who still live in Cuba despite many opportunities to stay abroad. They are not supporters of the regime, simply people who don't want to live away from their country and their families. But black-and-white vision doesn't allow for nuances.

The fact remains that of all the people in the world who were reading and marveling at Yoani, it was some Cuban exiles who made her wonder "maybe I should be in jail to prove I'm legit" -and it all came from her returning to Cuba after living abroad. That's the extent of the paranoia and it's pretty sad. It takes a big stretch of the imagination not just to think Yoani was a plot to advance some supposed Raul-as-reformist PR effort but also THAT was their first thought! It has to be! Cuban's can't access internet! Cubans are thrown in jail the second they write something critical! There are spies amongst us!

(It's illogical too, because you'll think if Cuba's state security was that good, they would not have chosen as a plant somebody who would raise suspicions as too good to be true. And if it was a plant, what was she exactly doing? One thing is to spy on organizations, another quite different is to post harsh criticism of the government openly. What would have been the purpose? Please. The real plants are in Kaos en la Red).

Dr. Hook: KC and CB had a different attitude and supported Yoani because they lived in Cuba and know people like her. That's the difference.

Anonymous said...

Anon asked: still don't get WTF Gomez is so torqued about?



Simple, many suspect that Babulu is not what they appear to be. Their repression of thoughts, and ideas. Their exposing of anti-Fidel bloggers. Their open exploitation of Cuba, in order to make a quick buck. And now this!! SFDB exposure of Babulu's vicious comments about Sanchez, is potentially crippling. SFDB has struck at the heart of Babulu's very creation.

As a result, Val (Henry is not smart enough) quickly realized the severe damage that Babulu would take to its carefully crafted anti-communist reputation. An (unearned) reputation that has recently taken several direct hits.

I know Val's pani to be real, as Val would break his vow of silence about SFDB, only if the situation seriously endangered Babulu. As is the case here.

In fact, i know other bloggers, who have spent the morning emailing Babulu's attacks on Sanchez to: Canf, Diaz brothers, Miami Chamber of Commerce, Alpha 66and many others.

As that blogger thinks it is important to know (exactly) who they are dealing with, when they deal with Babulu.

C.L.J. said...

Alex wrote:
But here's the question, how do you react the next time there's a Yoani? What irks me is the distrust as a knee-jerk, first-reaction. Fine, scrutinize anything that comes out of Cuba if that's what floats your boat, but does it has to be from a suspicious or skeptical point of view?

I have no problem with a skeptical point of view; that's a basis of sound philosophy. But skeptical does not mean you start out by questioning the integrity of a stranger. Skepticism is "I won't accept something as true until it's tested; but I also can't state that it is untrue until it has been tested."
No, what Babalu practices isn't skepticism; they practice Dogma: the adherence to a stated point of view regardless of any facts relevant to the matter.

Fantomas said...

I have no problem with a skeptical point of view; that's a basis of sound philosophy

I was skeptical at the beginning but mas merely saying that we needed more proof she was not being utilized by " someone"

So far she has proved me wrong

CJB-BCJ said...

Alex and Rick, if the two of you were to allow your "disagreements" (yes, I'm being conservative in my description) with whomever at Babalublog to become water under the bridge, perhaps even setup a private chat where only invited parties would participate, and agree to move forward while agreeing to disagree on whatever, both sides would not only benefit, all readers and future participants would also reap some kind of example (to say the least) that should be emmulated. Think about it guys, it really is a no brainer.

Fantomas said...

CJB-BCJ who paid ya to say that?

CJB-BCJ said...

Enrique Rubio aka Fantomas, are you planning on being a PITA here also?

Take a break Rubio, you don't have to be a prick everyday of your miserable life, you know.

Rick said...

Careful with the language, CJB-BCJ, you're awful close to being deleted.

.

CJB-BCJ said...

Apologies Rick, this fellow is a royal pain everywhere he comments, you'll soon learn, believe me.

Fantomas said...

CJB-BCJ who paid ya to say that?

Can you answer the question Sir

Post a Comment

Spam, vulgar language, trolling and off-topic comments are not tolerated at SFDB and your comment will be removed if it meets this criteria.